Pastoring the Pestering Conscience
June 1, 2026
June 1, 2026
Abstract: Trent Hunter offers biblical principles and practical suggestions to help pastors care for members with particularly sensitive consciences. Whether it’s through knowing their people well and proclaiming God’s grace clearly, through preaching, through a team of elders, or through one-on-one counseling, pastors should be intentional about speaking the truth in love to those who are pestered by their conscience.
“How do you pastor members who have extremely sensitive consciences?” Our elders asked this during my pastoral candidacy. They loved and knew their people. I made good use of Romans 14 in reply. But experience did not inform my answer.
Today, after eight years, it does.
Conscience is our moral faculty that assesses what is good and bad11 .This definition is from Kevin DeYoung, The Art of Turning: From Sin to Christ for a Joyfully Clear Conscience, pp. 13–14.—a unique feature of our humanity, not a bug. But the conscience can be buggy. A conscience may be seared so that an alarm does not sound when it should (1 Tim. 4:2). Or it may go off needlessly.
I’ve met church members who are hard on themselves. Like radar that mistakes birds for bombers, their consciences hold them in a state of emergency. They live under the threat of God’s judgment. They apologize a lot. Some are hard on others, too. Like air traffic controllers with defective equipment, they cry danger when there is none. They accuse a lot. They may mean well. Or they may despise rather than welcome their brothers and sisters (Rom. 14:10). The issues are many. Intensity levels vary.
How do we pastor members with extremely sensitive consciences? Our mind may jump immediately to the counseling appointment. We’ll get there. When we do, we’ll make good use of Paul’s model and instruction in Romans 14. But as I thought about my own pastoring, the whole of the ministry came into view.
Here are four venues for pastoring especially sensitive consciences.
We meet all kinds of consciences at the front door—that is, the membership class, a newcomers’ reception, or conversations after the service and over coffee. Each conscience is shaped by a different upbringing, the preaching they’ve been under, and the part of the country they’re moving from. Those with especially sensitive consciences are usually new believers or Christians deeply shaped by people who played a key role in their salvation or growth.
Here are a few ways to pastor the conscience at your church’s front door.
Our pews are lined with stories of burdened consciences set free by grace through the Word. This includes many who traveled in especially strict fundamentalist circles. You never know what the Lord will do in the life of your next guest. Let the joy of this good news be the first note you strike. Everyone needs to hear it, especially those with sensitive consciences.
This is just good hospitality. Teach on your Confession of Faith (what you believe together) and your Membership Covenant (how you live together). Get specific. Use Albert Mohler’s “Theological Triage” to illustrate why your church does not treat all differences alike.22 .Albert Mohler, “Theological Triage.” 9Marks, 2010. https://www.9marks.org/article/theological-triage/. Explain and illustrate how you guard the gospel by granting differences on tertiary matters.
“I don’t like the music” was something I was used to hearing in church work. But “God doesn’t like the music” was new to my ears after moving to my region.
We speak with guests about the priority of the congregation’s voice and the enhancing role of music. One guest asked, “Would the elders be willing to sign a statement stating they would never change the music at the church?” With love and candor, I replied, “No, we would not.” I explained, and he joined. He made no trouble when change came.
The topic of music illustrates this point as well. For years, we were well-led from the piano. In our search for a vocational director for congregational singing, we were flexible to be led by piano or guitar. We needed the right man with the right convictions. Understanding the sensitivity of some guests to what’s appropriate for the church’s worship, I’d say this in our receptions: “At Heritage, we are jealous to guard the congregation’s voice in our singing on Sunday. We’re led by piano. Down the road, we could be led by guitar. But our commitment to singing will remain.”
I don’t let my children condescend to one another. Neither do we despise one another as church members (Rom. 14:1, 10). We want our guests to pick up on a spirit of love and mutual affection in their earliest interactions with our church. This may require tough love at times. This doesn’t happen often, but sometimes a member lets their guard down with the pastor and makes a joke about members who take issue with alcohol (or vice versa). I don’t laugh. Sometimes I correct the attitude on the spot. They usually thank me later.
God sanctifies consciences through his Word, primarily through the pulpit. As James Montgomery Boice is famous for saying, church leaders overestimate what they can achieve in a short period but underestimate what can be done over the long term. That applies to shaping consciences as well.
Here are a few ways to pastor the conscience from the pulpit.
We don’t preach to rocks. Or animals. We preach to people with consciences that can both accuse and defend them—accurately or inaccurately (Rom. 2:14–15). So, let’s take our cues from the apostles who spoke about their own consciences in pursuit of a hearing: “My conscience is clear” (2 Cor. 1:12). Warn the flock by speaking of the “insincerity of liars whose consciences are seared,” unable to feel (1 Tim. 4:2). Appeal for purity by warning against a “defiled” conscience that approves what is evil and rejects what is good (Titus 1:15). Finally, preach the joy of a conscience cleansed by the blood of Jesus with which we draw near to God (Heb. 10:22). In short, be sure the conscience gets airtime in your preaching.
Do you have members who are teetotalers? Your audience should inform how you preach on Jesus’s transformation of water into wine in John 2:1–11. But don’t fail to preach the joy of the kingdom captured in the gift of wine. Be careful to avoid embracing strained interpretations to avoid touchy topics. Yes, the wine Jesus made was an alcoholic beverage, miraculously well-aged even. He saved the best for last (2:10).
Every community has an Overton window—a window of acceptable ideas and speech.33 .This idea is commonly used in discussions of what is politically possible at any moment based on what ideas are acceptable to the voting public. Joseph Overton suggested that politicians stay inside this window of acceptable ideas to avoid coming off as too extreme. Politicians will also strategize for how to move the Overton window to make currently unacceptable ideas seem attractive. By way of application, expositional preaching is the way we seek for God’s Word to define what is right and wrong, good and bad. Are there taboo topics in your church? If you’re doing book-by-book exposition, God eventually brings them up. Thankfully, when your text puts you outside the Overton window, you’re in good company. Here’s a suggestion: when you find your text outside the window, slow down. For my church, I slowed down in our series through Colossians. In four sermons through 2:16–23, we defined legalism, considered the various ways we undermine Scripture’s sufficiency, and mapped the path for deep inward change.44 .The following four sermons are an example of slowing down in a series to deal more surgically with a subject raised by the text. “The Problem of Add-On Christianity,” Colossians 2:16–23; “The Problem of Ultra-Biblical Christianity,” Colossians 2:17–18; “The Problem of Super-Spiritual Christianity,” Colossians 2:18–19; “The Problem of Extra-Pure Christianity,” 2:20–23; “Union with Christ, Power for Life,” Colossians 3:1–4.
The regular preacher also bears responsibility for the spirit of these discussions. How you talk is how they will talk. How you feel is how they will feel. Are you walking on eggshells to avoid upsetting people? That’s the kind of church you’ll have. Alternatively, are you feisty and dismissive toward those with more sensitive consciences? In the long term, that’s the kind of church you’ll have.
Don’t make fun of your differences. But do have some fun with them. One friend’s church was preaching through Genesis and tackled the age of the earth. Church members took different positions, and the topic could have gotten contentious. Here’s what those pastors did. The older pastor taught a lesson titled, “An Old Man for a Young Earth.” The younger pastor—say his name was Joe—taught by a different title, “A Young Man for an Old Earth.” The next week, a church member brought a sign, “Joe is not young, and the earth is not old.” There was nothing malevolent about it. These pastors effectively led their church to hold essentials and get along despite this difference.
Preaching is central, but not enough. Healthy churches need a stable of elders who shepherd the flock of God among them (1 Pet. 5:1–2). If the elders are not getting along on a topic broached by the Sunday sermon, the sheep will know. Elder teams do well to pursue the same mind on specific subjects as well as an overall approach to getting along with differences where they remain.
Here are suggestions for pastoring the conscience around the elder table.
Elders are to be examples to the flock, which includes how they relate with one another. Large teams like ours—pushing fifteen to twenty men at times—have a natural disadvantage in dealing with touchy topics. But eventually, taboo topics eat trust. It’s worth the work to get on the same page. Or if you can’t, work to agree on how to relate given your differences.
Every church has its issues. Elder teams can’t master every subject. But teams can get a working handle on the topics that keep coming up among their flock, or don’t but should. Our elders differed on the moral status and practice of alcohol, a reflection of our church’s differences. This was a taboo topic for us. So, we surveyed ourselves as a team to chart the spectrum of convictions and practices, then shared our experiences with alcohol personally and pastorally. Next, we read the relevant Scriptures and summarized our shared observations and differences. Third, we discussed and agreed on a way of relating to one another and the church, given our study. Differences remain, mostly in practice, but this is a non-issue now.
Elder teams should be able to discern the difference between a debatable matter and a matter of moral significance. A movie that depicts a murder is different than a film that displays a woman’s naked body. Those who object to the latter are not “weaker.” They’re seeing God more clearly, for the pure in heart shall see God (Matt. 5:8). “Pure in heart” is a thing.
What is worldliness? Should the church avoid cultural expressions that come from the world, whether clothes or music? John tells us, “For all that is in the world—the desires of the flesh and the desires of the eyes and pride of life—is not from the Father but is from the world” (1 John 2:16). Worldliness is loving only those who love you back, being anxious about your life, and bickering about who is the greatest (Luke 6:32; 12:22–31; Mark 10:42–44). That kind of thing. Moses came down the mountain and found idolatry, which is worldliness. The music and dancing at the foot of the mountain were problematic because they were to the wrong god (Exod. 32:19).
In addition to teaching and godly counsel, good books go a long way. I’ve used three. Andy Naselli and J.D. Crowley’s Conscience: What It Is, How to Train It, and Loving Those Who Differ offers a careful unpacking of its title. Our elders used this book to anchor our discussion on conscience issues. For a shorter treatment, try Kevin DeYoung’s The Art of Turning: From Sin to Christ for a Joyfully Clear Conscience. For a longer treatment, read Rediscover the Joy of a Clear Conscience by Christopher Ash. And for children, That Little Voice Inside Your Head by Andy Naselli.
Finally, we reach the one-on-one conversation—across the dinner table, the coffee table, or the table in your office. Here we take our lessons from Paul’s letter to the Romans, his famous fourteenth chapter. I’ve organized these lessons with five words for easy recall when you need them.
Before you head into your next meeting with a sensitive conscience, remember these five words.
With love for sensitive consciences, Paul commands us, “As for the one who is weak in faith, welcome him” (Rom. 14:1). Not everyone will. Because of their own over-accusing conscience, they may impose a sense of alienation on themselves. With great hesitation, one brother met with me to ask if it was okay if he stayed in our church even though he was bothered in his conscience by a certain church practice. With a little instruction and a lot of warmth, he remains with us today. Their conscience may condemn them. Others may despise them. Make sure they’re welcome with you.
With concern for sensitive consciences, Paul commands them, “Let not the one who abstains pass judgment on the one who eats, for God has welcomed him” (Rom. 14:3). This means they cannot leverage Paul’s command to the strong to manipulate the entire church to live just as they do. Neither should they leave the church because someone else has different thoughts or practices on a matter of conscience. This will require maturity on their part and instruction from you on how to discern a debatable matter. One of our elders is fond of asking, “Could a reasonable Christian read the Scriptures and take the other position?” Use that question.
On one hand, train this brother or sister to honor the Lord by obeying their conscience (Rom. 14:6, 12, 14). Remind them, “Whatever does not proceed from faith is sin” (14:23). On the other hand, train them to know when it’s time to disobey their conscience.55 .Andy Naselli, “Don’t Always Follow Your Conscience.” Desiring God, 2016. https://www.desiringgod.org/articles/dont-always-follow-your-consciencePaul’s choice of the word “weak” indicates that this is not a desirable condition (15:1). Where the conscience is misaligned with God’s Word, the Christian does well to recalibrate their conscience with uncomfortable obedience to Scripture. Concerning bacon, Jesus told Peter to “take up and eat.” Peter replied, “By no means, Lord” (Acts 10:14). But Jesus had the final word: “What God has made clean, do not call common” (Acts 10:15). Jesus is Lord over all, including the conscience.
Paul tells us to welcome the weak in faith, but added, “Do not quarrel over opinions” (Rom. 14:1). Reason with them from the Scriptures, but do not legitimize every opinion with debate. It is tempting. Some claims provoke. Some arguments are downright fanciful. Ask God for wisdom to know when to correct and when not to engage. Paul seemed to know what many of us have learned, that there is no end to such discussions.
This is not a condescending command: “We who are strong have an obligation to bear with the failings of the weak, and not to please ourselves” (Rom. 15:1). Or, as one friend put it, “Love them more than you hate where they are at.” Hang in there with them. Members with especially sensitive consciences are not in the way of ministry; they are your ministry. And they are partners in ministry. Learn from their obedience to what they believe the Lord requires.
The goal in all our efforts is a congregation marked by peace with God and one another.
Let us draw near with a true heart in full assurance of faith, with our hearts sprinkled clean from an evil conscience. (Heb. 10:22)
So then let us pursue what makes for peace and for mutual upbuilding. (Rom. 14:19)
This takes time. Consider the placement of these exhortations in their respective letters, ten and fourteen chapters in.
So, brothers, mind the front door. Shepherd your people from the front on the Lord’s Day. Pursue a unified front as elders. And get in front of your people one-on-one when they need you. Some with a pestering conscience need help, others need encouragement, and still others need rebuke. Be ready to administer the right medicine for the soul of each patient. And as Paul said, “Be patient with them all” (1 Thes. 5:14).
Walk with these sensitive—and sometimes over-sensitive—souls, one foot in front of the other.
Talk of “calibrating the conscience” often comes with two pastoral concerns: legalism in one corner and moral liberalism in the other.
Go to Journal →