Editor’s Note

Church Membership: Following the Lord Together
Journal
05.07.2019

“U. S. Church Membership Down Sharply in Past Two Decades” announced a recent Gallup headline. While membership in a church (plus synagogues and mosque) among U. S. adults hovered around 70 percent between 1938 and 1998, it proceeded to drop down to 52 percent between 1998 and 2018. Everyone from the Washington Post to the Huffington Post noticed.

Millennials (born 1980 to 2000) especially have been uninterested in joining a church. Only 42 percent belong to a church (plus synagogues and mosques), compared to 68 percent of Traditionalists (born before 1946), 57 percent of Baby Boomers (born 1946 to 1964), and 54 percent of Generation Xers (born 1965 to 1979). If millennials are the future, the future does not look bright for church membership.

Some church leaders, in response, want to do away with membership altogether. Ask less of attendees. Lower the bar of entry. This is not a generation of joiners, they’ll say, but doers. Let’s ask them to do.

No, others reply, America is more Vanity Fair than ever, its enticements and antagonisms bolder than ever. The dropping stats represent the dross of nominal Christians burning away. In 1938, real social advantages accrued to church members. By 1998, those public advantages had dissipated, but at least there were not yet disadvantages. Not so in 2018 and today, when the social cost of institutionally aligning oneself with Christianity grows with every passing month. We should therefore expect the well of Christians-in-name-only to dry up. Our solution should not be to lower the standards, but the opposite: to clarify what church membership is, including asking people to count the cost.

I belong to this latter camp. The lesson of the Gallup poll is that, more than ever, we need to understand this whole church membership thing. If something is going to cost us, I want to know it’s solid. That it’s Holy Spirit-inspired. I don’t assume that everyone in those surveys means what the Bible means when they check “yes” to the church membership box. If the culture is saying, “The time for one foot in, one foot out is over,” we should test the biblical basis of everything before we ask people to put both feet in. We all want to know we’re standing on something real.

Having said that, church membership might look a little different between Baltimore, Biloxi, and Bangkok. Real Bible stuff is bigger than our county, bigger than our country. Which means, we need to know how to talk about the biblical “elements,” which should be the same everywhere; and how to talk about the “forms” of those elements, which can be adjusted from place to place. Your elements are like furniture, while your forms are like the style of furniture. An oven is necessary for a kitchen, but one location might call for gas oven, another electric, and still another a wood-burning stove.

Like our previous 9Marks Journal on this topic, this Journal attends to both elements and forms. Several us think about membership from the Bible. Several more consider why it is crucial around the world and not just in the United States. And still more recommend different forms—what we call “best practices.” Also worth highlighting is the fact that church membership often has been abused. After all, membership involves the use of authority, and fallen sinners will abuse the good gift of authority. Authority biblically practiced, however, gives life.

Our goal is to give you something solid, something Christians can trust because it’s from the Bible. Whether the culture loves us or hates us, we all want to know how God means to mark off his saints, put them on display, sanctify them, and put them to work.

— Jonathan Leeman

By:
Jonathan Leeman

Jonathan Leeman is the Editorial Director of 9Marks, and an elder at Cheverly Baptist Church in Cheverly, Maryland. You can find him on Twitter at @JonathanLeeman.

Related Multimedia

Pastors Talk episode On Church Elders

Episode 96: On Church Elders (with Jeramie Rinne)

By Jeramie Rinne, Jonathan Leeman

The Heart of the Gospel: Penal Substitutionary Atonement

August 2019
Purchase a Print Edition
Church Membership: Following the Lord Together

Church Membership: Following the Lord Together

May 2019
Purchase a Print Edition

Ecclesiology for Calvinists

February 2019
Purchase a Print Edition
The Pastor and Pornography

The Pastor and Pornography

October 2018
Purchase a Print Edition

Pastoral Burnout: Its Causes & Cures

July 2018
Purchase a Print Edition

Church Life: Our True Political Witness

Spring 2018
Purchase on Amazon

Church Discipline: Medicine for the Body

January 2018
Purchase on Amazon

The Reformation and Your Church

Fall 2017
Purchase a Print Edition

Church Mergers and Plants

Summer 2017
Purchase a Print Edition

Pastoring Singles

Spring 2017
Purchase a Print Edition

Healthy Churches around the World

Fall / Winter 2016
Purchase a Print Edition

Authority: God’s Good and Dangerous Gift

Summer/Fall 2016
Purchase a Print Edition

The Church Praying

Spring 2016
Purchase a Print Edition

Confessions, Covenants, and Constitutions: How to Organize Your Church

Winter 2016
Purchase a Print Edition

Missions: Adding Wisdom to Zeal

Fall 2015
Purchase a Print Edition

Multi-Ethnic Churches

Summer/Fall 2015
Purchase a Print Edition

Expositional Preaching

Spring 2015
Purchase a Print Edition

Complementarianism & the Local Church

Winter 2015
Purchase a Print Edition

Vanishing Church?

Fall 2014
Purchase a Print Edition

Biblical Theology: Guardian and Guide of the Church

Summer 2014
Purchase a Print Edition

The Church Singing

May–June 2014
Purchase a Print Edition

Prosperity Gospel

January–February 2014
Purchase a Print Edition

Evangelism – Part 2

November–December 2013
Purchase a Print Edition

Evangelism – Part 1

September–October 2013
Purchase a Print Edition

Is Scripture Enough?

July–August 2013
Purchase a Print Edition

Church and Churches

May—June 2013
Purchase a Print Edition

Pastoring Christians for the Workplace

March—April 2013
Purchase a Print Edition

Lay Elders: A User’s Guide—Part 2

Jan—Feb 2013
Purchase a Print Edition

Lay Elders: A User’s Guide – Part 1

November—December 2012
Purchase a Print Edition

Discipling in the Church

September—October 2012
Purchase a Print Edition

Mercy Ministry in the Church

July—August 2012
Purchase a Print Edition

Wanted: Apostolic Pastors

May—June 2012
Purchase a Print Edition

The Underestimated Doctrine of Conversion

March—April 2012
Purchase a Print Edition

Don’t Be Too Cool for Sunday School

January—February 2012
Purchase a Print Edition

Revitalize: Why We Must Reclaim Dying Churches—and How

November—December 2011
Purchase a Print Edition

The Pastor and his Staff, Part 2

September—October 2011
Purchase a Print Edition

The Pastor and his Staff, Part 1

July—August 2011
Purchase a Print Edition

Church Membership: Holding the Body Together

May—June 2011
Purchase a Print Edition

Church and Parachurch: Friends or Foes?

March—April 2011
Purchase a Print Edition

Pastoral Moves

January—February 2011
Purchase a Print Edition

Book Reviews on the Mission of the Church

November—December 2010
Purchase a Print Edition

Hell: Remembering the Awful Reality

September—October 2010
Purchase a Print Edition

Pastoring Women

July—August 2010
Purchase a Print Edition
Journal about Deacons

Deacons

May - June 2010
Purchase a Print Edition

A New Evangelical Liberalism

January—February 2010

Church Discipline (Part 2)

November—December 2009

Church Discipline (Part 1)

September—October 2009

Missions

July—August 2009

Multi-site Churches

May—June 2009

Young Pastors

March–April 2009

Raising Up the Next Generation of Pastors

January–February 2009

Counseling in the Church

November–December 2008

Family & Parenting

September–October 2008

Marriage & Pastor’s Wives

July—August 2008

Living As a Church

May–June 2008

Cooperation

March–April 2008

Corporate Prayer

January–February 2008

Church & Culture

November–December 2007

Race and Ethnicity

September—October 2007

The Gospel

July–August 2007

Preaching

May–June 2007

Elders (Part 2)

March–April 2007

Hospitality & Friendship

January 2007

Elders (Part 1)

February 2007

Biblical Theology

November–December 2006

The Church’s Mission

October 2006

The Emerging Church

September 2006

Miscellaneous Articles

December 1999